Open Letter to Good Housekeeping

Well – here goes! After many suggestions to start my own blog, many moons spent thinking about it, what feels like forever in trying to understand wordpress….here forth begins myBlog!

I suspect it will become a little bit of everything – I’m a fashion girl at heart but after the last year of craziness, I’d really like to talk about Mental Health.
This wasn’t something I wanted to talk about at first. Few people knew when I was first signed off with Anxiety with Depression in March 2015. Those that did were banned from talking. It took another 7 months for me to start being a lot more open – now you’d struggle to stop me!
Because of this, I thought it fitting for my first “blog” to be the open letter I’ve just written to Good Housekeeping Magazine RE an article in their February 2016 issue..
Karen xx
Dear GH

Let me start by saying; I love your magazine. I’m 28 so potentially one of your youngest readers and I don’t expect your target market, but ever since my mum had a subscription I’ve always loved reading GH. I honestly believe it is one of few remaining decent magazines that doesn’t glorify this new world culture of Z-List “Celebrities” that are famous for not really being famous, for example, the likes of “The Only Way Is Essex”, “Made In Chelsea”, etc. Television I’ve never watched – because I’d much rather be reading a good book or a good article; developing my imagination further or learning. Or living my life rather than wasting it in front of a box watching pointless endless waffle dumbing down my brain. I’ve suffered serious mental health issues the last year and because of this I feel like I’ve lost a huge amount of me, of my ability to focus or concentrate on anything for much longer than 30 seconds. I can’t read a book at the moment; because I take in nothing and loose focus quickly. After being signed off work for a third time I finally decided to leave. I’m lucky I am supported physically, mentally, financially, by my husband (and wider family) to be able to essentially “retire” at the age of 28. I digress – my point being that I struggle to concentrate and learn at the moment – my brain already feels “dumbed down” without adding to it by watching this kind of endless rubbish on television, so I have always admired GH for focussing on genuine, hardworking, talented celebrities – real actors, singers, musicians – or even the likes of real GOOD members of the public contributing vastly to society. Proper articles, interesting reads, no focus on how “thin” so-and-so looks or how much weight so-and-so has gained, etc.

I regularly make recipes from your magazines, in particular the “Energy Boosting Bars” which I edit from January 2015. Everyone I share them with enjoys them and feels like they’ve had a healthier treat. In fact as I typed some of this email I was mid way through preparing a batch.

I was pretty surprised, therefore, to notice this weekend your latest edition with the title “switch on your skinny gene – I lost 7 lbs in 7 days!” blazoned across the front in bright orange font. My weight fluctuates between a healthy 8 stone – 9.7 stone regularly. It does so because despite now being an adult and knowing what foods, exercise, lifestyle choices etc, work for my body, I still consistently find myself engulfed in disordered eating thoughts stemmed from an 18 year on-off battle with Anorexia Nervosa. I do not believe I will ever fully get over this battle. I do believe I can contribute to others not having to go through this battle – if I am ever lucky enough to have children of my own I will work tirelessly to ensure they do not have an unhealthy attitude towards food and exercise. The recommended and healthy weight loss is 1-2 lbs a week. For someone who is insanely obese – a half stone weight loss in a week would be easy for someone really working at it – however still probably not healthy. At 9 stone which is perfectly healthy for my age and height, I can still loose half a stone in a week. But I should not be able to: It is not healthy. At my worst I buy baby food snacks because they are lower calorie. I keep the packaging until they are all gone so I can keep track of those exact calories. I fill myself up on diet fizzy drinks. I weigh out every morsel of food; salad leaves included. I can force myself to eat little and move more. I track everything. My shockingly low recommended calorie goal provided to me by a tracking app on my phone; I always fight to be lower than. At best I’ll eat anything and everything but this too often comes with consequences; I’ll throw up, take laxatives, run further. it is this kind of disordered eating which has me wondering if I will ever conceive.
I didn’t have time to read the article initially. I wasn’t sure I wanted to; I was so disappointed, GH, that you seemed to have broken your morals and stopped to the levels of every other magazine in essentially encouraging rapid, unhealthy, unsustainable weight loss, and glorifying eating disorders in doing so. Eventually, I succumbed. I wanted, needed, to see what you had to say. Whilst I appreciate you admitted it was an out of character article for GH; I still feel it has been advertised in the wrong way; bright orange font glaring out at those so susceptible and desperate to loose weight in any possible way; proven by the fact that it was the first thing I noticed within a rare visit to a supermarket; it is what drew me to the magazine before I even realised it was GH. The article itself is reasonably sensible; talking down “fad” diets and discussing eating foods rich in nutrients, but that’s where it ends. You talk about no severe calorie restriction; however I would think that restricting to 1000 calories for 3 days and then a maximum of 1500 calories for the rest does sound somewhat extreme; and I am disappointed that although “staying active” is mentioned; there is no talk of a healthy amount of weekly exercise involved with the diet; I am no expert, but I suspect this is probably because it is a grossly restricted calorie diet, which leaves you with little left to burn in healthy exercise. I still feel like after a week, and people go back to eating “normally” that half a stone would quickly be put back on. The best way to loose weight and keep it off, if this is what you really want; is to eat well. Proper, whole foods, fruit, veg. Less refined sugars and ready meals. Cook from scratch. Exercise.

Please, please, rethink who you are. What you stand for – the wonderful magazine who embraces real women. I think there is a dying breed of this REAL woman. Healthy eating, healthy exercise, healthy attitudes, are the best way to lead this short time we get to live.


2 thoughts on “Open Letter to Good Housekeeping

  1. Yay! So glad you’ve started to blog πŸ˜‰ Love the post and the look of the blog – the home page picture is gorgeous. I wonder if GH will reply – it makes me scream when I see articles like that. I always find it two-faced because I bet somewhere else in the magazine is an article about self-belief!! You’re an inspiration, keep it up πŸ™‚ xx


    1. Thank you! πŸ€—πŸ€— took me long enough! I had to use our laptop – for some reason the desktop didn’t want me to post at all! This is the one I messaged you about earlier – it’s taken me ever since to try again! Haha!
      They actually have replied via email – I’m not sure they entirely get my point though…I’m working on that 😊


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s